E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars became an instant hit because it did what so many great stories do: it captured our imaginations with its impeccable blend of suspense, family drama, and emotional turbulence. But just when we thought we had unlocked all the secrets of the Sinclair family, Lockhart pulls us back in with Family of Liars, the prequel we didn’t know we needed but now can’t live without! If you thought the Sinclairs were dysfunctional before, get ready to see how it all began!
Book Review: Family of Liars
Content Warnings: grief, loss, manipulation, gaslighting, mental health struggles, family dysfunction, toxic relationships, suicidal ideation, drug abuse, and implied violence
Summary: A windswept private island off the coast of Massachusetts. A hungry ocean, churning with secrets and sorrow. A fiery, addicted heiress. An irresistible, unpredictable boy. A summer of unforgivable betrayal and terrible mistakes. Welcome back to the Sinclair family. They were always liars.
Set years before the tragic events of We Were Liars, Family of Liars takes us on a deep dive into the origins of the Sinclair family’s web of lies, guilt, and privilege. Told through the eyes of Carrie Sinclair, the younger sister of We Were Liars’ Cadence, this story takes us back to the golden days of the Sinclair family, just before everything came crashing down!
The Sinclair Family You Thought You Knew…But Don’t
The Sinclairs have always been a family of wealth, beauty, and hidden pain. In Family of Liars, we meet Carrie, who offers a fresh perspective on the family’s deeply rooted dysfunction. Carrie’s narrative brings a new layer to the mystery, offering insight into the emotional complexities and choices that led to the disaster we saw in We Were Liars. If you were wondering how the pieces fit together, this book does exactly that, peeling back the layers of secrets with a careful, methodical touch.
What stands out in Family of Liars is the way it captures the heavy burden of privilege, creating a gilded cage that traps the Sinclair family. The mansion on the island may appear idyllic, but there’s a storm brewing beneath the surface. Lockhart’s writing shines as she deftly weaves in the tension, creating a setting where danger feels inevitable, and no one escapes unscathed!
Secrets, Lies, And The Weight Of Family History
At its core, Family of Liars is about the mistakes of the past and how they haunt the present. The Sinclair family’s love story is entangled with lies that have been buried for years. What makes this book so compelling is that it doesn’t just focus on one event but traces the gradual unraveling of trust between family members. You get to witness the moments that, at first glance, seem insignificant but, in retrospect, mark the beginning of a downward spiral.
The writing is nothing short of hypnotic. Lockhart’s prose flows with a lyrical quality that mirrors the luxurious yet suffocating world the Sinclairs inhabit. As Carrie peels back the layers of the family’s secrets, you start to understand how the past shaped the future. The tension is palpable, and it feels like the characters are constantly on the edge of an emotional cliff, teetering between redemption and disaster.
The Emotional Heartbeat Of The Story: Carrie Sinclair
Carrie, as the narrator, offers an emotional depth that wasn’t as apparent in We Were Liars. While Cadence’s story in the original novel is filled with grief and guilt, Carrie’s perspective opens up a new emotional dynamic. She’s struggling to make sense of her own identity within a family that is full of contradictions. The pressure to live up to the Sinclair family’s perfect image is overwhelming, and as Carrie navigates her own coming-of-age journey, you feel the weight of her internal conflict. The stakes are personal and high, making it impossible to look away.
What’s also fascinating is how Family of Liars shows the generational nature of family trauma. The patterns of behavior and the mistakes made by one generation are mirrored in the next, creating a cycle of dysfunction. Carrie’s emotional journey feels like an attempt to break free from the sins of her predecessors, but in a family like the Sinclairs, it’s easier said than done!
A Twist That Will Leave You Breathless
Of course, Lockhart is no stranger to plot twists. If you thought the story couldn’t get more intense, Family of Liars takes a shocking turn that leaves you questioning everything you thought you knew about the Sinclairs. The ending is unexpected, emotional, and will have you turning the pages faster than you can process. Let’s just say, if you’re a fan of plot twists, you’ll want to read this with a seatbelt on!
And if you’re still holding on to the memory of We Were Liars and how it ended, Family of Liars will make you reconsider the Sinclair family’s journey as a whole. It’s the perfect companion to the original book, giving you a fuller understanding of the lies that were laid long before the tragic events we saw unfold.
A TV Show Adaptation? Yes, Please!
If you haven’t seen it yet, make sure to check out the TV adaptation, which delves even deeper into the Sinclair family’s emotional turmoil. With Family of Liars as the foundation, the series promises to explore the mystery even further, making it one of the most anticipated adaptations of the year. Fans of the book will be hooked, eagerly watching as these gripping stories unfold on-screen!
What do you think about Family of Liars? Let us know all your thoughts in the comments below or over on Twitter, Instagram, or Facebook!
Want more book reviews? Check out our library!
TO LEARN MORE ABOUT E. LOCKHART:
FACEBOOK | INSTAGRAM | WEBSITE | X
