There’s something cruel about a happy memory. It hands you a beautiful place to return to, then reminds you the door is locked. Sometimes, if we’re being honest, the memory starts to look better than anything waiting for you tomorrow. Lygia Day Peñaflor’s Beautiful to See You (Again) takes that ache and makes it literal. What if you could actually go back?
Tia Cruz Adlon isn’t living the life she once planned. She dropped out of Columbia and now spends her days walking dogs around New York City, cut off from the ambitions that used to define her. Then she finds a mysterious tunnel in Central Park, one that carries her back to the summer she fell in love with Natty Poole, a romance that ended in tragedy. Here’s the catch. The tunnel lets Tia visit that summer, but it won’t let her make everything right, and every trip leaves her weaker. We can’t think of anything more heartbreaking than a second chance with strings attached!
Book Review: Beautiful to See You (Again)
Content Warnings: grief, death of a loved one, trauma, addiction and rehab, abusive relationship, infidelity, mild cussing, off-page sexual content
Summary: Two years ago, she fell in love with her high school’s valedictorian Natty, the awkward boy who’d always adored her. But their summer together ended in tragedy. Now, instead of attending Columbia, Tia works as a dog walker, drifting through New York City and avoiding the future.
Then she discovers a hidden tunnel in Central Park…a tunnel that can take her back: back to Natty and their glorious summer, the summer she thought was gone forever.
But every visit comes at a cost. The more time Tia spends trying to change the past, the harder it becomes to return to the present—where the ambitious film student, Razor Ford, is determined to cast her in his short film…and maybe even pull her out of her grief and remind her that life is still waiting for her.
Caught between then and now, Tia must decide between holding on to what she’s lost—or moving forward to what might be the bravest love story of all.
Why Does A Happy Memory Hurt So Much?
We romanticize the past. Hindsight makes even ordinary moments feel extraordinary. A conversation you barely noticed at the time becomes something you’d give almost anything to live through again. Peñaflor builds a whole story around that longing. The time travel does more than move the plot along. It gives physical shape to a very human wish: the chance to stand in the moment before grief or heartbreak changed the direction of your life.
Tia and Natty sit at the emotional center. The alternating timelines let you feel the gap between a summer full of promise and a present Tia is barely getting through. She does more than remember Natty. She’s sliding toward a life built around getting him back, and that’s a different thing entirely. The novel never treats her grief as an obstacle that vanishes once a new romance shows up.
Is This Really A Love Triangle?
Enter Razor Ford, an ambitious film student who wants Tia to star in his short film. He opens a door in a life that has narrowed around what Tia lost.
Don’t expect the usual contest where you pick a favorite fictional boyfriend and defend him until the end of time. Natty stands for a love tied to one moment in Tia’s life, the moment she can’t stop revisiting. Razor stands for the uncertainty of letting someone new into a future she’s barely considered.
That difference matters. Moving forward can feel like betrayal while you’re still attached to what came before. You can know, in your head, that life can’t stay suspended forever and still not be ready to accept it. The better question is whether Tia can see that choosing to live again doesn’t shrink the love she had.
What Does Central Park Add To The Story?
Central Park gives Beautiful to See You (Again) an atmosphere that suits the premise. Its strange architecture and the city humming around it do a lot of the work. There’s something whimsical about finding an impossible passageway in a place you thought you knew.
A dog-walking job, a student film, a hidden tunnel, and a summer that refuses to stay in the past sound like ingredients from four different books. Here they come together around one grounded question. The speculative side also gives Peñaflor room to explore regret without leaning on the mechanics of time travel. We read the novel as a story about the cost of refusing to accept what happened, with the time travel as the vehicle.
Can You Really Live In A Memory?
Time travel stories love to pose as second chances. We picture ourselves going back to fix a mistake or say the thing we never got to say. Then comes the harder question. What happens when the chance to revisit a moment becomes the very thing keeping you from moving on? That’s where this book finds its footing. Peñaflor’s novel is melancholy and romantic with a touch of fantasy, and its central worry is easy to recognize. You don’t need a tragic first love to understand the pull of a life that no longer exists. Sometimes you miss a person. Sometimes you miss who you were when that person was part of your days. The two feelings get hard to separate.
Fair warning if you want a fast, breezy romance! The alternating timelines and contemplative pace won’t work for everyone. The emotional weight comes from sitting with Tia’s longing instead of rushing her toward an easy answer. Staying with that uncertainty and a story that treats grief as complicated rather than convenient pays off. Beautiful to See You (Again) asks something harder than whether you’d travel through time if you could. What if you could revisit the happiest days of your life, and every return cost you a little more of the life you still have? Would you keep going back? Maybe the best thing a second chance can show you is that your future is worth showing up for!
Beautiful to See You (Again) treats grief as complicated rather than convenient.
What do you think about Beautiful to See You (Again)? Be sure to let us know in the comments below or over on X, Instagram, or Facebook!
Want more book reviews? Check out our library!
